Does visibility in AI pay off? What the data says, and what it does not
Traffic from ChatGPT and other AI assistants is usually less than 1% of a site’s visits today, so on its own it rarely pays for itself. What pays is something else: when Google shows an AI summary, people click a result almost half as often, and four in ten Poles already use AI tools. Below are the numbers, their sources and what they do not prove.
By Piotr ZientaraPublished Updated
How much traffic AI sends today
Not much. SE Ranking, a company that sells SEO tools, counted the traffic of 101,574 sites from January to April 2026: AI assistants sent 0.32% of visits, search engines 42.75%. For every visit from AI, a search engine sent more than a hundred.
The agency Amsive found the same on 54 sites in 2025: language models brought 0.24% of sessions and 0.42% of conversions.
The share is growing, but unevenly. In the same SE Ranking data, AI traffic in the European Union grew 33% year on year, then fell 12% within three months.
What happens to clicks when AI answers
This is a stronger argument than AI traffic itself. Pew Research Center, an independent research organisation, analysed 68,879 searches by 900 US adults from March 2025. When Google showed an AI summary, people clicked a result in 8% of visits. Without one, in 15%. About 1% clicked a link inside the summary itself. A summary appeared in 18% of searches.
Ahrefs, a company that sells SEO tools, examined 300,000 keywords: at position one next to an AI Overview, the click-through rate in December 2025 was 1.6%. Ahrefs links AI Overviews to a click-through rate about 58% lower, but compares it with its own forecast, not with a measurement.
Google says otherwise. In August 2025 it wrote that total clicks from Search to websites are “relatively stable” year on year. It gave no figures.
What this means for a business: fewer people click through from an AI answer, but some customers still read which brands the AI names and decide on that basis. Seer Interactive, an agency, noticed on the keywords of 42 clients that brands cited in AI Overviews had a higher click-through rate than brands that were not. Seer itself says this is a correlation, not proof that being cited causes more clicks.
Is a visitor from AI worth more?
The data disagrees, so it is not worth assuming.
- Amsive compared conversion on 54 sites: 4.87% from language models and 4.60% from search. The difference is not statistically significant.
- Adobe, which sells analytics tools, reported that in the 2025 holiday season AI traffic to US retail sites grew 693% year on year. That is growth from a small base, which Adobe does not give.
- The often repeated “23 times better conversion” comes from one company: Ahrefs measured it on its own site over 30 days and itself doubts it carries over to others. In Ahrefs’ wider study of 81,947 sites, visitors from AI left straight away more often (67.8% against 63.7% from search) and viewed fewer pages (4 against 5.2).
What it means in Poland
- According to GUS, Statistics Poland, 39.8% of people aged 16–74 used AI tools in the past three months. A year earlier, 22.7%.
- In an SW Research survey from April 2026 (830 people, reported by ITwiz), 61% of respondents had used AI tools when shopping in the past six months, most often to compare products and services.
- Google’s AI Overviews have worked in Polish since March 2025, and AI Mode in Poland since October 2025.
Customers already ask AI before they buy. Even if they do not click a link, they remember the names they heard.
How to check whether it pays for you
Other people’s averages do not replace your own numbers. Three steps:
- In Google Analytics, check how many visits came from ChatGPT, Gemini or Perplexity, and multiply by your conversion rate and average order value. That is what AI traffic is worth to you today.
- Add the question “How did you hear about us?” to your forms, with the answer “From ChatGPT or another AI”. It catches customers who heard of you from AI but arrived another way, for example by typing your address.
- Ask ChatGPT and Gemini a few questions your customers ask, and check whether they name your brand and cite your site. AlfaUMi Monitor does this step every week.
What this data does not tell you
- Most studies come from the US and from companies that sell SEO tools or services.
- Some results are correlations: they show that two things go together, not that one causes the other.
- We found no independently verified example of a small business that measured its revenue from visibility in AI.
- The numbers change fast: the same share can rise and fall within a quarter.
Read more: GEO Guide
Check your own site
The free analysis shows in a minute how search engines and AI assistants see your site.
Analyze freeFrequently asked questions
Does traffic from ChatGPT pay off?
Rarely on its own: today it is usually less than 1% of visits. What counts is whether AI names your brand when a customer asks about your category, because some customers will not click, they will remember the name.
Do AI Overviews take clicks away?
In Pew’s 2025 study, people clicked a result in 8% of visits with an AI summary instead of 15%. Google says total clicks are relatively stable, but gives no figures.
Where do I start?
With your own data: how many visits from AI Google Analytics shows, what customers answer to “How did you hear about us?”, and whether AI assistants name your brand.
Sources
- Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results · Pew Research Center,
- Update: AI Overviews Reduce Clicks by 58% · Ahrefs, · vendor study
- AI in Search: Driving more queries and higher quality clicks · Google,
- AIO Impact on Google CTR: September 2025 Update · Seer Interactive, · vendor study
- Analysis of Top AI Search Engines: Who Is Catching Up to ChatGPT? · SE Ranking, · vendor study
- Does LLM Traffic Convert Better Than Organic? A New Data-Backed Study · Amsive, · vendor study
- Adobe: Holiday Shopping Season Drove a Record $257.8 Billion Online with Consumers Embracing Generative AI Tools · Adobe, · vendor study
- Does AI Search Traffic Convert Better Than Traditional Search? For Ahrefs, Yes: 0.5% of Visitors Drove 12.1% of Signups · Ahrefs, · vendor study
- AI Visitors Visit Fewer Pages and Bounce More Often Than Traditional Search Visitors · Ahrefs, · vendor study
- Społeczeństwo informacyjne w Polsce w 2026 r. · GUS,
- Już 61% Polaków korzysta z chatbotów AI podczas zakupów · ITwiz,
- Funkcja „Przegląd od AI” teraz dostępna w większej liczbie krajów Europy · Google Polska,
- Wyszukiwarka Google: wprowadzamy Tryb AI w Polsce · Google Polska,